In a week where Alex McLeish joined Birmingham’s bitter rivals Aston Villa, and in a time where people ask for loyalty from players, how about a little bit of loyalty from this list of Gaffers! Each one of the men I am about to list would of preached that there is no loyalty in football, but then they go and join a bitter rival.
1) Ron Saunders, Aston Villa to Birmingham City
What happened? Having won the 1981/82 league title, bullet-headed Saunders clashed with Doug Ellis – who had been in exile during the title run – over control of transfer policy and walked out on Villa in February 1982 with his club in the European Cup quarter-finals. Nine days later he walked into St Andrews.
Fans’ reaction? Supporters on both sides were gobsmacked and largely sympathetic to Saunders, with Blues fans glad to have a winner on board and the Villa faithful beginning a hate-hate relationship with Ellis.
Was he a success? Though Villa went on to win the European Cup under Tony Barton, Blues endured mixed fortunes under Saunders’ guidance. After struggling for two seasons, they were eventually relegated in 1983/84, before being promoted the following year. Saunders jumped ship in 1986, this time moving to another Midlands rival, West Bromwich Albion.
2) Harry Redknapp, Portsmouth to Southampton to Portsmouth
What happened? After numerous clashes with former chairman Milan Mandaric, Redknapp quit as Portsmouth manager on November 24 2004. He appeared to be close to returning a week later, when Mandaric hugged him at a bizarre press conference called to clarify remarks about the manager he had made in another bizarre press conference after his resignation. But on December 8, having being caught on camera telling a Pompey fan “am I joining that lot down the road? No chance”, Redknapp became Southampton manager, leading them to relegation. Just under a year later, on December 7 2005, he was back at Fratton Park.
Fans’ reaction? Frenzied. Southampton had to hire a bodyguard for Redknapp, while Portsmouth fans waved ‘Judas’ signs and sported ‘Harry Scummer’ T-shirts when he returned to Fratton and sang ‘Judas, Judas, what’s the score?’as their team routed Saints 4-1. All was forgiven when he returned – with Soouthampton supporters largely glad to see the back of him. And winning the FA Cup with a side of highly-paid veterans helped make him a Freeman Of Portsmouth. Alas, the day before Redknapp picked up the award, he quit now cash-strapped Pompey for Tottenham and when the mayor of Portsmouth opened his speech by saying “I don’t really know what to call this man”, a disgruntled fan shouted, “How about Judas?” and was ejected from the ceremony.
Was he a success? His days at St Mary’s ended in miserable failure, with the club being relegated for the first time in 27 years, and then failing to mount a successful promotion campaign. On the other hand, his return to Portsmouth marked a golden era in the club’s history, with Redknapp managing to keep the club in the top flight, achieve respectable league finishes in successive seasons, and famously winning the FA Cup in 2008, with a 1-0 victory against Cardiff City.
3) George Graham, Arsenal to Tottenham
What happened? The Scot had led Arsenal to six major trophies during his nine years at Highbury before running into bung trouble in 1995. Having served a one-year ban, he returned to football to sort out Leeds United and took them into Europe, but was tempted by a return to North London with the Gunners’ greatest rivals in October 1998.
Fans’ reaction? Indifference on the Arsenal side as supporters were beginning to fall in love with Arsene Wenger’s football after years of pragmatism under Graham. Open dislike on the Tottenham side, with Graham unforgiven for his Arsenal links. Famously, fans never sang his name, leading to memorable chants like “bloke in a coast’s blue-and-white army”. Graham scoffed at calls for a return to “the Tottenham Way”, pointing out if had returned precisely one title in 40 years. And he called the influential Tottenham Action Group “professional whingers”.
Was he a success? Just five months after taking charge at Spurs, Graham led the club to victory over Leicester City in the ill-tempered 1999 League Cup Final – their club’s first trophy in eight years. Other than this, Graham’s side stumbled in mid table mediocrity, with a best finish of 10th, and few Lilywhites shed a tear when he was sacked over a contract dispute March 2001.
4) Terry Neill, Tottenham to Arsenal
What happened? After a 21-year playing career at Arsenal, Neill was an unsurprisingly unpopular choice to succeed Tottenham legend Bill Nicholson as manager in 1974. Two years later, having barely kept Spurs up in his second season, the Irishman walked out to replace another ledge, Bertie Mee, at Highbury.
Fans’ reaction? On the Spurs side, bemused but not really bothered as rumour had it that Neill frequently used a spiritualist to help with team selections. Gooners welcomed back their former idol with some misgivings – Neill was still only 34, and had hardly set White Hart Lane alight.
Was he a success? His seven-year stay as Arsenal boss was relatively successful. The Gunners reached three successive FA Cup finals and the UEFA Cup final but only won one. However, the side never really reached their full potential with star players like Malcolm Macdonald, Pat Jennings and Liam Brady failing to consistently perform under Neill’s tutelage.
5) Alan Ball, Portsmouth to Southampton to Portsmouth
What happened? After two spells at Southampton as a player, the World Cup winner joined Portsmouth as manager in 1984 and lasted five mostly successful years. Five years and two jobs later, he joined Southampton before quitting for a disastrous spell at Manchester City. Ball returned to Fratton Park in 1998 in what would prove to be his last job in management.
Fans’ reaction? Despite the history of hatred between Skates and Scummers, Pompey fans ddn’t blame Ball too much for joining Saints as he’d been forced out of Portsmouth in a personality clash with unpopular chairman Jim Gregory. Southampton fans welcomed him back with opoen arms, remembering his successful spells in red and white stripes as a player. However, his decision to return to Fratton Park in 1998 was met with a certain degree of antipathy by both sets of fans.
Was he a success? At Southampton, Ball coped well with the pressure of relegation, by managing to maintain the club’s Premier League status in the 1993/94 season. The following year, impressive signings, including Bruce Grobbelaar, together with the form of Matt Le Tissier, propelled the Saints into an impressive 10th position. Ball’s propensity for relegation battles was on show when he took over at Portsmouth, and masterminded a miraculous escape from the second tier’s drop zone at the end of the 1997/98 season while old club City went down instead .
6) Danny Wilson, Sheffield Wednesday to Sheffield United
What happened? A success at Wednesday as a player (three Wembley finals and a League Cup win) but a relative failure as an Owls boss, Wilson was appointed manager of their deadly rivals the Blades on May 27th 2011.
Fans’ reaction? The decision to appoint Wilson was greeted with derision and anger among Blades fans. supporters. He arrived at Bramall Lane to face a mob of 400 protesters, one carrying a banner reading ‘Love United, Hate Wilson’, and cries of “Wilson Out” could be heard during his introductory press conference, with fan John Whiteley telling the local papers: “It’s the worst appointment I’ve seen in the 45 years I’ve been a Blade.” The anti-Danny demo was duly recorded in the Sheffield Star under the genius headline ‘Wilson Picket’.
Success? Remains to be seen, but Wilson faces a very difficult job in managing to convince fans that he is capable of guiding the club back into the big time again.
7) Brian Clough, Derby to Nottingham Forest
What happened? The outspoken character enjoyed promotion and title success with Derby County, before a controversial departure in October 1973, charted with reasonable faithfulness in the book and film The Damned Utd. After brief and unsuccessful spells at Brighton and Leeds, he joined the Rams’ then-lowly East Midlands arch rivals Nottingham Forest in January 1975.
Fans’ reaction? Clough was an immensely popular figure at Derby, and his decision to take over at the City Ground was met with uproar by the Pride Park faithful. Not so at Forest, where fans had been circulating a petition to bring Old Big ‘Ead to the City Ground since his Elland Road dismissal in September 1974. Yet Clough continued to live in Derby and as Forest’s fortunes improved and the Rams declined, he achieved popularity even in the town which despises the Tricky Trees. Today, there are statues of the great man in both Derby and Nottingham.
Was he a success? Clough proved himself to be one of the world’s greatest manager during his 18 years in charge of Forest. He guided them to the First Division title, two successive European Cups, and four League Cups before a sad and booze-soaked relegation.
8) Peter Taylor, Derby to Nottingham Forest to Derby
What happened? Despite a feud with Clough over Taylor’s 1980 tell-all book, the Forest paid fulsome tribute to his loyal assistant when Taylor retired in May 1982. Yet six months later the “genius coach” was back in football with Forest’s deadly rivals and enraged Clough by buying winger John Robertson from Forest while Clough was on holiday. The pair never spoke again and for the next two years, with each living in in the other town, they drove past each other on the way into work every day without even exchanging a wave.
Fan reaction? The Forest faithful, stoked up by Clough, were outraged as Taylor’s betrayal of his former friend. Derby fans were grateful to see him stolen away from the enemy, although the attraction quickly paled when it became clear he would not take Derby back to the top flight.
Was he a success? Taylor managed to steer Derby away from the bottom of the old Division Two table and even beat Clough’s Forest in the third round of the FA Cup. But financial problems at the club meant he was never able to mount a serious bid for honours and when he resigned in April 1984 Derby were again back in the drop zone.
9) Radomir Antic, Real Madrid to Atletico Madrid to Barcelona
What happened? The man who kept Luton Town in the top flight with the goal which relegated Manchester City in 1983 got his second managerial job with Real in 1991, then had outstanding success with local rivals Atletico after a brief spell with Real Oviedo. He had three stints as manager there and returned to Oviedo before joining Barcelona.
Fans’ reaction? Remembered fondly by fans of all three teams, Antic is baffled by the increasing enmity between Real and Barca. He said recently: “The rivalry between both clubs has gone too far. Football has continually been in the background and non-sporting issues have made the headlines. I really can’t understand this.”
Was he a success? Antic had his greatest success at Atletico, when he led the club to its first League and Domestic Cup double in 1996. He might have done similar at Real, where he signed Luis Enrique and Robert Prosinecki while converting Fernando Hierro into a midfielder, and Barca, where he blooded Andres Iniesta and moved Xavi into the hole. On both occasions, club politics led to his departure.
10) Leonardo, AC Milan to Inter
What happened? Citing conflicts with bunga-bunga enthusiast, Italian PM and AC Milan owner, the club’s Brazilian boss quit in May 2010, waving goodbye to the club he served with distinction as a player in the late 1990s. However, Leonardo was back at San Siro with Inter by December, replacing unpopular Rafa Benitez.
Fans’ reaction? Inter’s fans were not overjoyed about the prospect of a Milan legend becoming their new manager. However, this was offset by their disillusionment with Benitez’s performance and their craving for change. On the other side, AC Milan chief executive Adriano Galliani said he “would never forgive” Leonardo, but later claimed he had been joking. Galliani also described Berlusconi as “not a self-serving person and he is not bossy”, so he’s obviously got a well-developed sense of humour.
Success? Leonardo started off fairly well in the blue side of the City, managing to finish runners up in the league (behind their rivals, unfortunately), and winning the Italian Cup with victory over Palermo. But he always seemed uncomfortable at Inter and left in June 2011 to join Paris St Germain.